吉红;朱天和;单世涛;

• 1:西北农林科技大学动物科技学院
• 2:西北农林科技大学水产科学研究所
• 3:陕西省饲料厂

摘要：

鱼粉的全球性缺乏已成为制约水产增养殖业可持续发展的重要影响因素。作者综述了近年来在非肉食性鱼类日粮中用动植物蛋白源替代鱼粉方面的研究成果,对替代后造成的负面影响(生产性能下降,生理和免疫机能降低,肉质品质劣化等)进行了总结,并对其原因和对策进行了归纳、分析和探讨,旨在为非肉食性鱼类低鱼粉乃至无鱼粉日粮的开发提供思路和基础资料。

关键词： 非肉食性鱼类;动植物蛋白源;鱼粉

Abstract: The unstable fishmeal supply has become the bottleneck of the global aquaculture practice.Although there has been extensively studied in the field of dietary fishmeal replacement,most researches focused on the marine carnivorous species.Aiming to the potential application of animal and plant protein sources for non-carnivorous fish,the present paper summarized the negative effects caused by the dietary fishmeal replacement practice,such as retarded growth performance,poor physiological and immunological status,and low fillets quality.On the other hand,the possible approaches,including the application of amino acids product,functional addictives into the diet to improve the pattern of dietary amino acid composition,acceptance and digestive character of the diet,also the physiological function of hepatopancrease and liver,etc,were also discussed.It is mentioned that the study about the dietary fishmeal replacement for non-carnivorous fish species served as an important way for the sustainable progress of aquaculture.

Keywords: animal and plant protein sources;non-carnivorous fish;fishmeal

基金项目: 陕西省科技厅农业攻关项目(2006K01-G1-2);; 西北农林科技大学安康水产试验示范站建设项目(Z222020020)

通讯作者:

Email:

参考文献：

• [1]FAO.The states of world fisheries and aquaculture 2006:Part 1,World reviewof fisheries and aquaculture[C]//Food and Agricul-ture Organization of the United Nations,Rome,2007.
• [2]Krishnankutty N.Plant proteins in fish feed:an additional analysis[J].Curr Sci,2005,89(6):934-936.
• [3]周歧存,麦康森,刘永坚,等.动植物蛋白源替代鱼粉研究进展[J].水产学报,2005,29(3):404-410.
• [4]Pitchaya C,Shuichi S,Tokuya H,et al.Availability of geneticallymodified soybean meal in rainbow troutOncorhynchus mykissdiets[J].Fish Sci,2006,72:1072-1078.
• [5]Alvarez J S,Hernandez-Llamas A,Galindo J,et al.Substitution offishmeal with soybean meal in practical diets for juvenile whiteshrimpLitopenaeus schmitti(P rez-Farfante&Kensley 1997)[J].Aquacult Res,2007,38:689-695.
• [6]Pham M A,Lee K J,Lim S J,et al.Evaluation of cottonseed andsoybean meal as partial replacement for fishmeal in diets for juven-ile Japanese flounderParalichthys olivaceus[J].Fish Sci,2007,73:760-769.
• [7]Yang Y,Xie S,Cui Y,et al.Effect of replacement of dietary fishmeal by meat and bone meal and poultry by-product meal ongrowth and feed utilization of gibel carp,Carassius auratus gibelio[J].Aquacult Nutr,2004,10:289-294.
• [8]Li MH,Peterson B C,Janes C L,et al.Comparison of diets contai-ning various fish meal levels on growth performance,body composi-tion,and insulin-like growth factor-I of juvenile channel catfishIctalurus punctatusof different strains[J].Aquaculture,2006,253:628-635.
• [9]Siddhuraju P,Becker K.Preliminary nutritional evaluation of mu-cuna seed meal(Mucuna pruriensvar.utilis)in common carp(Cyprinus carpioL.):an assessment by growth performance andfeed utilisation[J].Aquaculture,2001,196:105-123.
• [10]Gaber M M.Partial and complete replacement of fish meal bybroad bean meal in feeds for Nile tilapia,Oreochromis niloticusL.,fry[J].Aquacult Res,2006,37:986-993.
• [11]Zhang S,Xie S,Zhu X,et al.Meat and bone meal replacement indiets for juvenile gibel carp(Carassius auratus gibelio):effects ongrowth performance,phosphorus and nitrogen loading[J].AquacultNutr,2006,12:353-362.
• [12]Hasan MR,Macintosh D J,Jauncey K.Evaluation of some plantingredients as dietary protein sources for common carp(CyprinuscarpioL.)fry[J].Aquaculture,1997,151:55-70.
• [13]El-Saidy D MS D,Dabrowski K,Bai S C.Nutritional effects ofprotein source in starter diets for channel catfish(Ictalurus puncta-tusRafinesque)in suboptimal water temperature[J].AquacultRes,2000,31:885-892.
• [14]Cai X,Luo L,Xue M,et al.Growth performance,body composi-tion and phosphorus availability of juvenile grass carp(Ctenopha-ryngodon idellus)as affected by diet processing and replacement offishmeal by detoxified castor bean meal[J].Aquacult Nutr,2005,11:293-299.
• [15]Jahan P,Watanabe T,Kiron V,et al.Improved carp diets basedon plant protein sources reduce environmental phosphorus loading[J].Fish Sci,2003,69:219-225.
• [16]Siddhuraju P,Becher K.Comparative nutritional evaluation of dif-ferentially processed mucuna seeds[Mucuna pruriens(L.)DC.var.utilis(Wall ex Weight)Baker ex Burck]on growth perform-ance,feed utilization and body composition in Nile tilapia(Oreo-chromis niloticusL.)[J].Aquacult Res,2003,34:487-500.
• [17]El-Saidy D MS D,Gaber MM.Replacement of fish meal with amixture of different plant protein sources in juvenile Nile tilapia,Oreochromis niloticus(L.)diets[J].Aquacult Res,2003,34:1119-1127.
• [18]Fasakin E A,Serwata R D,Davies S J.Comparative utilization ofrendered animal derived products with or without composite mixtureof soybean meal in hybrid tilapia(Oreochromis niloticus,Oreochro-mis mossambicus)diets[J].Aquaculture,2005,249:329-338.
• [19]Schulz C,Wickert M,Kijora C,et al.Evaluation of pea protein i-solate as alternative protein source in diets for juvenile tilapia(Oreochromis niloticus)[J].Aquacult Res,2007,38:537-545.
• [20]叶元土,薛敏,林仕梅,等.草鱼肠道、肝胰脏对饲料蛋白质酶解速度的比较[J].中国水产科学,2003,10(2):173-176.
• [21]Hasan M R,Haq M S,Das P M,et al.Evaluation of poultry-feather meal as a dietary protein source for Indian major carp,La-beo rohitafry[J].Aquaculture,1997,151:47-54.
• [22]计成,杨久仙.饲料中抗营养因子及复合酶制剂的应用效果[M]//冯定远.酶制剂在饲料工业中的应用.北京:中国农业出版社,2005:38-43.
• [23]Riche M,Trottier N L,Ku P K,et al.Apparent digestibility ofcrude protein and apparent availability of individual amino acids intilapia(Oreochromis niloticus)fed phytase pretreated soybean mealdiets[J].Fish Phy Bioch,2001,25:181-194.
• [24]Olvera-Novoa M A,Martinez-Palacios C A,Olivera-CastilloL.Utilization of torula yeast(Candida utilis)as a protein source indiets for tilapia(Oreochromis mossambicusPeters)fry[J].Aquac-ult Nutr,2002,8:257-264.
• [25]Abdelghany A E.Partial and complete replacement of fish mealwith gambusia meal in diets for red tilapia‘Oreochromis niloticus×O.mossambicus’[J].Aquacult Nutr,2003,9:145-154.
• [26]Borgeson T L,Racz V J,Wilkie D C,et al.Effect of replacingfishmeal and oil with simple or complex mixtures of vegetable in-gredients in diets fed to Nile tilapia(Oreochromis niloticus)[J].Aquacult Nutr,2006,12:141-149.
• [27]El-Saidy D M S D,Gaber M M,Abdelshafy A.Evaluation ofcluster bean mealCyamposis tetragonolobaas a dietary proteinsource for common carpCyprinus carpioL.[J].J World AquacultSoc,2005,36(3):311-319.
• [28]Murai T,Ogata H,Kosutarak P,et al.Effects of amino acid sup-plementation and methanol treatment on utilization of soy flour byfingerling carp[J].Aquaculture,1986,56(3-4):197-206.
• [29]叶元土,蔡春峰,蒋蓉,等.鱼粉、豆粕、菜粕、棉粕、花生粕对草鱼生长和生理机能的影响[J].饲料工业,2005,26(12):17-22.
• [30]吉红,朱天和,周继术.日粮中鱼粉添加量对鲤鱼种生长、生物学性状及血清生化指标的影响[J].西北农林科技大学学报:自然科学版,2008,36(7):33-39.
• [31]Sitj偄-Bobadilla A,Pen-Llopis S,G幃mez-Requeni P,et al.Effect of fish meal replacement by plant protein sources on non-specific defence mechanisms and oxidative stress in gilthead seabream(Sparus aurata)[J].Aquaculture,2005,249:387-400.
• [32]张锦秀,周小秋,刘扬.去皮豆粕对幼建鲤生长性能和肠道的影响[J].中国水产科学,2007,14(2):315-319.
• [33]Francis G,Makkar H P S,Becker K.Anti-nutritional factorspresent in plant-derived alternate fish feed ingredients and theireffect in fish[J].Aquaculture,2001,199:197-227.
• [34]姜光丽,周小秋.大豆分离蛋白对幼建鲤肝胰脏发育及消化道蛋白酶活力的影响[J].大连水产学院学报,2005,20(3):198-202.
• [35]Rinchard J,Mbahinzireki G,Dabrowski K,et al.Effects of dietarycottonseed meal protein level on growth,gonad development andplasma sex steroid hormones of tropical fish tilapiaOreochromissp.[J].Aquacult Inter,2002,10:11-28.
• [36]Yildirim-Aksoy M,Lim C,Wan P,et al.Effect of natural freegossypol and gossypol-acetic acid on growth performance and re-sistance of channel catfish(Ictalurus punctatus)toEdwardsiellaictalurichallenge[J].Aquacult Nutr,2004,10:153-165.
• [37]Garcia-Abiado MA,Mbahinzireki G,Rinchard J,et al.Effect ofdiets containing gossypol on blood parameters and spleen structurein tilapia,Oreochromissp.,reared in a recirculating system[J].JFish Dise,2004,27:359-368.
• [38]De Francesco M,Parisi G,M啨dale F,et al.Effect of long-termfeeding with a plant protein mixture based diet on growth andbody/fillet quality traits of large rainbow trout(Oncorhynchusmykiss)[J].Aquaculture,2004,236:413-429.
• [39]Hern偄ndez MD,Mart姫nez F J,Jover M,et al.Effects of partial re-placement of fish meal by soybean meal in sharpsnout seabream(Diplodus puntazzo)diet[J].Aquaculture,2007,263:159-167.
• [40]Khan MA,Jafri A K,Chadha N K,et al.Growth and body com-position of rohu(Labeo rohita)fed diets containing oilseed meals:partial or total replacement of fish meal with soybean meal[J].Aquacult Nutr,2003,9:391-396.
• [41]李惠,黄峰,胡兵,等.发酵豆粕替代鱼粉对斑点叉尾鮰生长和饲料表观消化率的影响[J].淡水渔业,2007,37(5):41-44.
• [42]El-Saidy D M S D,Gaber M M.Complete replacement of fishmeal by soybean meal with dietary L-lysine supplementation forNile tilapiaOreochromis niloticus(L.)fingerlings[J].J WorldAquacult Soc,2002,33(3):297-306.
• [43]Furuya W M,Pezzato L E,Barros MM,et al.Use of ideal proteinconcept for precision formulation of amino acid levels in fish-meal-free diets for juvenile Nile tilapia(Oreochromis niloticusL.)[J].Aquacult Res,2004,35:1110-1116.
• [44]El-Sayed A-F M.Total replacement of fish meal with animalprotein sources in Nile tilapia,Oreochromis niloticusL.,feeds[J].Aquacult Res,1998,29:275-280.
• [45]Refstie S,Storebakken T,Roem A T.Feed consumption and con-version in Atlantic salmon(Salmo salar)fed diets with fish meal,extracted soybean meal or soybean meal with reduced content of ol-igosaccharides,trypsin inhibitors,lectins and soya antigens[J].Aquaculture,1998,162:301-312.
• [46]姜光丽,周小秋.不同大豆蛋白对幼建鲤蛋白质沉积的影响[J].大连水产学院学报,2005,20(2):81-86.
• [47]Peres H,Lim C,Klesius P H.Nutritional value of heat-treatedsoybean meal for channel catfish(Ictalurus punctatus)[J].Aqua-culture,2003,225:67-82.
• [48]刘文斌,尹君,方星星,等.3种益生素配伍对异育银鲫(Car-assius auratus gibelio)生长、消化及肠道菌群组成的影响[J].海洋与湖沼,2007,38(1):29-34.
• [49]王纪亭,吴淑勤,石存斌,等.非淀粉多糖酶对奥尼罗非鱼生产性能和饲料消化率的影响[J].中国畜牧杂志,2006,42(3):37-40.
• [50]吉红.鱼用植物性蛋白饲料的抗营养因子[J].水利渔业,1999,19(4):22-23.
• [51]Refstie S,Sahlstrom S,Brathen E,et al.Lactic acid fermentationeliminates indigestible carbohydrates and antinutritional factors insoybean meal for Atlantic salmon(Salmo salar)[J].Aquaculture,2005,246:331-345.
• [52]Mukhopadhyay N,Ray A K.Effects of amino acid supplementa-tion on the nutritive quality of fermented linseed meal protein in thediets for rohu,Labeo rohita,fingerlings[J].J Appl Ichthyol,2001,17:220-226.
• [53]Xue M,Cui Y B.Effect of several feeding stimulants on diet pref-erence by juvenile gibel carp(Carassius auratus gibelio),fed di-ets with or without partial replacement of fish meal by meat andbone meal[J].Aquaculture,2001,198:281-292.
• [54]Sardar P,Randhawa HS,Abid M,et al.Effect of dietary microbi-al phytase supplementation on growth performance,nutrient utiliza-tion,body compositions and haematobiochemical profiles ofCypri-nus carpio(L.)fingerlings fed soyprotein-based diet[J].Aquac-ult Nutr,2007,13:444-456.
• [55]Barros MM,Lim C,Klesius P H.Effect of soybean meal replace-ment by cottonseed meal and iron supplementation on growth,im-mune response and resistance of channel catfish(Ictalurus pucta-tus)toEdwardsiella ictalurichallenge[J].Aquaculture,2002,207:263-279.
• [56]Violaa S,Mokady S,Rappaport U,et al.Partial and complete re-placement of fishmeal by soybean meal in feeds for intensive cul-ture of carp[J].Aquaculture,1982,26:223-236.
• [57]刘永坚,田丽霞,刘栋辉,等.实用饲料补充结晶或包膜赖氨酸对草鱼生长、血清游离氨基酸和肌肉蛋白质合成率的影响[J].水产学报,2002,26(3):252-258.
• [58]Carvalho A P,Sa R,Oliva-Teles A,et al.Solubility and peptideprofile affect the utilization of dietary protein by common carp(Cyprinus carpio)during early larval stages[J].Aquaculture,2004,234:319-333.
• [59]Segovia-Quintero M A,Reigh R C.Coating crystalline methio-nine with tripalmitin-polyvinyl alcohol slows its absorption in theintestine of Nile tilapia,Oreochromis niloticus[J].Aquaculture,2004,238:355-367.
• [60]Jian J-Ch,Wu Z-H.Influences of traditional Chinese medicineon non-specific immunity of Jian carp(Cyprinus carpiovar.Jian)[J].Fish&Shell Immunol,2004,16:185-191.
• [61]Rao Y V,Chakrabarti R.Stimulation of immunity in Indian majorcarpCatla catlawith herbal feed ingredients[J].Fish&Shell Im-munol,2005,18:327-334.
• [62]王艳,吴志新,庞素风,等.果寡糖对银鲫非特异性免疫功能的影响[J].水生生物学报,2008,32(4):488-492.
• [63]王锐,刘军,刘辉宇,等.半乳甘露寡糖对异育银鲫幼鱼生长和非特异性免疫的影响[J].上海水产大学学报,2008,17(4):502-506.
• [64]Li P,Gatlin D MIII.Review article:Nucleotide nutrition in fish:Current knowledge and future applications[J].Aquaculture,2006,251:141-152.